What changes?
- Tellow has a free plan, Moneybird does not.
- Paid plans at Moneybird start cheaper: €4 against €12.99 per month.
- Only Tellow integrates with RegioBank and Knab.
- Only Moneybird integrates with ABN AMRO, bunq, Mollie, Shopify, WooCommerce and Lightspeed.
From the Netherlands check and the prices, checked on the vendors' websites. See the comparison.
What do you take with you?
Exporting from Tellow
- Accounts
Rapportage > Exporteren > file type and period: CSV or audit file. Including balance sheet, VAT per quarter, companies, people, journal entries, transactions and invoices.
Tellow help page - After cancelling
After cancelling you can no longer log in. Tellow recommends exporting first.
Tellow help page
Not found on Tellow's website: which version of the audit file (XAF) Tellow produces. Ask them.
Not found on Tellow's website: a download of all sales invoices as PDF in one go. Ask them.
Importing into Moneybird
- Your old accounts
Importing everything in one go is not possible. You choose between an opening balance and entering your data retroactively. For large volumes Moneybird refers to the API.
Moneybird help page - Contacts
Contacten tab > Importeren, as CSV, Excel (.xlsx) or vCard. With CSV, contact persons are not included, and .xls does not work.
Moneybird help page - Opening balance
By hand, as a journal entry: Inkomend > Toevoegen > Of doorgaan zonder document > Memoriaal, for example on 31 December of the previous year.
Moneybird help page - Outstanding invoices
Only as a total on Debiteuren or Crediteuren in the opening balance. Entering them per customer or supplier is not possible; they then show as an unknown contact.
Moneybird help page - Bank statements
Bank tab > Toevoegen, as MT940 or CAMT.053 (Moneybird recommends CAMT.053). CSV is not possible.
Moneybird help page - Products
Importing is not possible, only through the API.
Moneybird help page
Not found on Moneybird's website: an import of an audit file (XAF). Ask them.
Not found on Moneybird's website: a migration service from Moneybird itself. Ask them.
Step-by-step plan
Choose a switch date. The simplest is the start of a financial year, otherwise the start of a VAT period.
Complete everything in Tellow up to that date: invoices, receipts and bank transactions. File the VAT return for that period from Tellow.
Export what you need from Tellow: at least the audit file, your contacts and your invoices. Keep the files with your records.
Add your contacts in Moneybird and enter the opening balance on the switch date, with the outstanding invoices.
Connect your bank in Moneybird from the switch date, so that no transaction comes in twice or not at all.
Keep your invoice numbers running. Start in Moneybird with a number that did not exist in Tellow.
Only cancel Tellow once everything has moved and you have checked the export.
Pitfalls
- Financial year
If you switch in the middle of a financial year, your annual figures come from two packages. You then have to combine them for your annual accounts.
- VAT return for the current quarter
Make sure one package has all the revenue and costs of a VAT period. If part is in the old package and part in the new one, it is easy to count something twice or miss something.
- Bank feed
Let the bank feed in the new package start on the switch date. If the dates overlap, you get transactions twice.
- Outstanding invoices
Include unpaid invoices from customers and suppliers in the opening balance. If the new package can take them per invoice, do that: then you can match the payment to the invoice later.
- Record retention
You must keep your records for 7 years, and data on real estate for 10 years. So export everything before you cancel, even if you do not need it in the new package.
- Invoice numbers
Invoices get sequential numbers, in one or more series, and each number may only occur once. So do not start again at 1 in the new package if that number already exists.
Frequently asked questions
How do I switch from Tellow to Moneybird?
Choose a switch date, preferably the start of a financial year or VAT period. Complete everything in Tellow up to that date: invoices, receipts and bank transactions. File the VAT return for that period from Tellow. Export what you need from Tellow: at least the audit file, your contacts and your invoices. Keep the files with your records. Add your contacts in Moneybird and enter the opening balance on the switch date, with the outstanding invoices.
What can I export from Tellow?
According to Tellow's help pages: accounts and after cancelling. For each item, this page shows how and where.
What can I import into Moneybird?
According to Moneybird's help pages, it covers your old accounts, contacts, opening balance, outstanding invoices, bank statements and products. For each item, this page shows how, and what is not possible.
What is the difference between Tellow and Moneybird?
Tellow has a free plan, Moneybird does not. Paid plans at Moneybird start cheaper: €4 against €12.99 per month. Only Tellow integrates with RegioBank and Knab. Only Moneybird integrates with ABN AMRO, bunq, Mollie, Shopify, WooCommerce and Lightspeed.
Sources
- https://help.tellow.nl/nl/articles/3000768-hoe-exporteer-ik-gegevens-uit-tellow
- https://help.tellow.nl/nl/articles/6389787-hoe-kan-ik-mijn-abonnement-annuleren
- https://www.moneybird.nl/helpcenter/nl/articles/207241-overstappen-naar-moneybird
- https://www.moneybird.nl/helpcenter/nl/articles/207516-contacten-toevoegen-aan-je-administratie
- https://www.moneybird.nl/helpcenter/nl/articles/207967-beginbalans-of-openingsbalans-opstellen
- https://www.moneybird.nl/helpcenter/nl/articles/207969-openstaande-facturen-in-de-beginbalans
- https://www.moneybird.nl/helpcenter/nl/articles/207567-transactiebestand-uploaden
- https://www.moneybird.nl/helpcenter/nl/articles/207605-product-aanmaken
- Belastingdienst: How long must you keep records? (in Dutch)
- Belastingdienst: Invoice requirements (in Dutch)
Help pages checked on . Menus and features change; the vendor's help page is what counts. Is something no longer correct? Let us know.
We get a fee if you take out a subscription through us. That does not change our verdict.
